- 1-888-479-0741
- sales@dotcom-monitor.com
- Minneapolis, MN, USA
Dotcom-Monitor
Website Monitoring & Performance Testing
What Is End to End Testing? How Does It Work?
End-to-end testing, also called E2E testing, is an aspect of software testing and quality assurance that verifies the functionality and performance of a software program from start to finish. It involves testing the entire software stack, including user interfaces, APIs, databases, and integrations with external systems. Its primary aim is to validate the software’s behavior, uncover any defects that may arise during the complete user journey, and ensure the software meets its intended objectives.
An automated testing tool is crucial in end-to-end testing. It facilitates the creation and execution of test cases that simulate complex user behaviors and validate the information flow within the application, ensuring the proper functioning of the entire software stack.
Modern software, with simultaneous interactions among multiple systems, highlights the importance of end-to-end testing. Even if individual components operate well in isolation, their integration with other systems may present challenges. End-to-end testing ensures all software system components work together. Software testers use this approach to detect and resolve issues that may arise at any touchpoint between software components and subsystems.
Significance of End-to-End Testing
End-to-end testing is applied in various scenarios and systems. Below are examples highlighting the applications of end-to-end testing in different system architectures and testing contexts.
Multi-tier Systems
Complex systems with multiple layers require end-to-end testing to ensure better connectivity and workflow across different stages. It verifies the smooth flow of work through various tiers, validating interactions between components and subsystems.
Backend Testing
End-to-end testing allows for testing the hidden layers of a software system, such as the database and application layers. By validating the functionality and performance of these backend layers, end-to-end testing validates the functionality and stability of the program.
Consistent User Experience
User experience should remain consistent across different platforms, devices, and work environments to provide a satisfactory experience to users. As part of the end-to-end testing, front-end testing helps confirm the consistency of the user interface, interactions, and user experience across various settings.
Distributed Environment
Applications in cloud environments involve several interconnected components and services. Continuous end-to-end testing is crucial in such distributed environments to validate the various components’ integration, functionality, and performance and ensure uninterrupted communication and data exchange.
Integration Testing
End-to-end testing tests the interactions and compatibility between different systems, modules, or services. By simulating real-world scenarios, end-to-end testing verifies the smooth flow of data and processes across integrated components, identifying any issues or discrepancies that may arise during system integration.
Workflow and Business Process Validation
End-to-end testing is essential to validate the flow of operations in systems with complex workflow or business processes. This testing approach ensures the system functions correctly and delivers the expected results throughout the workflow.
Cross-Platform Testing
End-to-end testing validates software compatibility across different operating systems, browsers, and devices. It ensures the software performs as intended and provides a consistent user experience across different platforms and devices.
Continuous Integration and Deployment
End-to-end testing is crucial to continuous integration and deployment (CI/CD) pipelines. It ensures that the software is thoroughly tested across all stages, including development, integration, and deployment, to detect any issues or regressions that may arise during the automated release process.
End-to-End Testing Lifecycle
The end-to-end testing lifecycle consists of four key elements:
- Test planning
- Test design
- Test execution
- Results analysis
Test Planning
Test planning involves defining the objectives, scope, and approach for end-to-end testing. It includes identifying the testing goals, determining the resources and timelines, and establishing the test environment. During this phase, the testing team collaborates with stakeholders to understand the requirements and define the test strategy. Test planning sets the foundation for the subsequent end-to-end testing phases.
Test Design
A suitable testing environment is established based on the specifications in the test design. This involves using an existing test environment or designing a new one. Risk analysis and resource utilization analysis are conducted to allocate resources. Test cases are also developed to cover the required scenarios.
Test Execution
During test execution, the test cases are executed both locally and remotely. Test execution can be manual, automated, or both, depending on the nature of the application and available resources. Test results are continuously monitored to ensure they align with the original test plan. Any deviations or issues encountered during the execution are recorded and communicated to the development team for prompt action.
Results Analysis
Test results are reviewed in the result analysis phase. The testing team compares the actual and expected results to determine if the software meets the desired quality standards. If any defects are identified, they are logged, prioritized, and reported to the development team for resolution. Results analysis also involves generating test reports and providing feedback to stakeholders regarding the application’s readiness for release.
End-to-End Testing Methods
Horizontal Test
In end-to-end testing, the horizontal method tests across multiple modules or layers parallel to each other in the system architecture. It validates the integration and communication between various system elements, such as user interfaces, APIs, databases, and external systems—for instance, an online ordering system, where different parts need to work together. The Horizontal Test verifies if user accounts, product inventory, and shipment information are correctly integrated into the system.
Vertical Test
Vertical test accesses each transaction of an application. It starts from the top layer and systematically evaluates each subsequent application layer. Let’s take an example of a web application that utilizes HTML to communicate with web servers. In such cases, an API is necessary to generate SQL codes for interacting with the database. Given the complexity of these computing scenarios, it becomes crucial to perform thorough validation and focused testing.
End-to-End testing combines the advantages of white-box and black-box testing methods. It verifies software or program functioning using functional and architectural approaches. Testers prefer this type of testing because it helps prevent significant faults, such as missing bugs or creating test cases that do not validate real-world scenarios. When creating test cases for end-to-end testing, it is essential to consider the end user, test current system features, account for various circumstances, and focus on different system scenarios. The test cases are considered to pass if the desired results are obtained. Otherwise, a rerun is required while identifying areas of failure.
How to Perform End-to-End Testing
The steps involved in conducting end-to-end testing are as follows:
Step 1: Define Test Scenarios
Identify and document the specific test scenarios that need to be executed. These scenarios should closely mimic real user interactions, encompassing all program elements and supporting systems.
Step 2: Set up the Test Environment:
Create a test environment that resembles the production environment to ensure reliable and accurate testing results. This involves configuring hardware, software, network, and other components to mirror the actual deployment environment.
Step 3: Execute Test Scenarios
Run the defined test scenarios, encompassing both functional and non-functional tests. Functional tests evaluate whether the software meets the desired specifications, while non-functional tests assess performance, security, and usability. Use both manual and automated testing techniques to achieve comprehensive test coverage.
Step 4: Evaluate Test Results
Analyze the results obtained from the testing phase to identify any weaknesses or issues that require attention. Prioritize the identified issues based on their impact on the application and severity level.
Step 5: Reporting and Tracking
Document all issues encountered during testing and assign the appropriate team member responsible for addressing each issue promptly. Maintain a systematic tracking mechanism to monitor the progress of issue resolution.
Step 6: Retest and Verify Fixes
Once the issues have been addressed, retest the application to verify the effectiveness of the fixes. Ensure the applied fixes resolve the identified problems without introducing new issues or regressions.
Step 7: Final Sign-Off
Once all identified errors have been rectified and retested, obtain final sign-off from the relevant stakeholders to indicate that the software is ready for release.
By adhering to these steps, development teams can establish a professional approach to end-to-end testing, enhancing the quality and reliability of the software application.
Benefits of End-to-End Testing
There are several benefits of performing end-to-end testing. Some of the benefits include the following.
Ensures Application Correctness and Health
During end-to-end testing, the software application undergoes comprehensive testing at various levels, including data, business rules, integration, and display, to ensure its correctness and integrity.
Enhance Confidence
End-to-end testing is performed across multiple platforms and devices to verify the application’s intended functionality and increase confidence in its performance.
Mitigate Risks
By conducting thorough testing after each sprint and iteration, end-to-end testing reduces the probability of future failures, thus reducing potential risks.
Reduce Repetitive Efforts
End-to-end testing facilitates more thorough testing, leading to fewer instances of failure and subsequently reducing the need for repetitive testing efforts.
Save Cost and Time
Automating end-to-end testing allows for fewer testing cycles. This saves time and cost during application maintenance and enhancement processes.
Enhance User Experience
End-to-end testing ensures a smooth and seamless experience for the end users by testing the entire user journey. It verifies that all features, functions, and interactions work as intended, providing a reliable and user-friendly application.
End-to-End Testing Challenges
Although end-to-end testing offers several advantages, it also comes with some challenges. Here are common challenges of end-to-end testing:
Complexity and Time-Consuming Nature
End-to-end testing involves testing the entire application stack, including multiple modules, interfaces, and systems. This complexity often leads to lengthy test execution times, making it time-consuming and resource-intensive. Coordinating and synchronizing various components and dependencies can be challenging, especially in large-scale applications with intricate workflows.
Test Environment Setup and Maintenance
To perform end-to-end testing, a stable test environment is set up which mirrors the production environment. This involves configuring and integrating various systems, databases, servers, and third-party services. Maintaining the test environment becomes crucial as changes or updates in any component can affect the entire testing process. Ensuring data integrity and consistency across multiple settings can be difficult.
Test Data Management
End-to-end testing requires various test data to simulate different scenarios. Managing and maintaining test data can be complex, especially when the application interacts with external systems or involves complex data dependencies. Generating and maintaining test data that covers various edge cases and scenarios can be challenging. Additionally, ensuring data privacy and regulatory compliance is crucial, especially when dealing with sensitive information.
Debugging and Issue Isolation
Identifying the root cause of failures or issues in end-to-end testing can be challenging due to the interconnected nature of the application components. When a failure occurs, it can be challenging to isolate the exact point of failure, especially when multiple systems or interfaces are involved. Debugging and troubleshooting such issues often require in-depth knowledge of the entire application stack, making it time-consuming and complex.
To mitigate these challenges, it is essential to:
- Plan and design end-to-end tests carefully
- Automate repetitive tasks
- Use appropriate test data management techniques
- Collaborate closely with development teams to ensure effective issue resolution and continuous testing process improvement.
End-to-End Testing Success Metrics
Essential metrics are used to gauge the effectiveness and efficiency of end-to-end testing. They include the following:
- Test Case Preparation Status: This helps determine the exact position of the test cases currently being prepared in relation to the scheduled test cases.
- Test Progress Tracking: It is recommended to track the progress of tests every week. This stage provides regular updates on the percentage of test completion, including test cases that have been executed, passed or failed.
- Defects Status and Details: Weekly updates regarding the proportion of open and closed defects are provided. The distribution of defects each week is based on their severity and priority.
- Environment Availability: This includes information on the actual operational hours and the daily testing hours scheduled for the testing environment.
End-to-End Testing Best Practices
Prioritize Critical Workflows
Focus on essential features and workflows of your application. Divide them into minor phases to ensure a better understanding of the testing process.
Avoid Exception Testing
Exception testing involves testing the system or behavior under error states or unusual occurrences. While it is a recommended practice, it is not suitable for end-to-end testing. Exception tests may reveal issues but fail to provide insights into the cause or the impact on the system or application.
Minimize UI Flakiness in Tests
End-to-end testing frequently includes UI tests because user interactions can be unpredictable. However, these tests are susceptible to failure. Network issues, slow servers, and other variables can lead to false positives. To handle such inconsistencies, it is recommended to account for unexpected system issues when running tests. For example, testers can use Katalon’s Smart Wait feature, which delays initiating predefined actions until all screen components have finished loading.
Leverage Automation Testing
Automation tools and frameworks can automate repetitive tasks, improving efficiency and accuracy. This approach enables faster test execution, enhances test coverage, and allows frequent testing iterations, leading to more reliable software systems.
End-to-End Testing – Key Takeaways
End-to-end testing is crucial for ensuring the delivery of high-quality software applications. By thoroughly assessing an application from start to finish, end-to-end testing verifies that it functions as intended, improving its features’ speed, security, and user-friendliness.
To achieve successful end-to-end testing, it is essential to have a comprehensive understanding of the application’s requirements and develop extensive test cases that cover all its functionalities. Additionally, leveraging automation technologies can facilitate regular and systematic testing, enhancing efficiency and reliability.
End-to-end testing instills confidence in the overall software quality and assures developers and testers that their program is ready for production deployment. Ultimately, this boosts user satisfaction, customer loyalty, and revenue, making it a critical practice for delivering exceptional software.
Learn More About Industry Monitoring Tools
